Given

Watched Given. I thought it was 12 episodes long, but it’s only 11. I was surprised at how fast it went by…
My main criticism of the manga was that the story wasn’t given enough room to breathe (even if that gave it a certain unique intensity). This (as I expected) isn’t the case in the anime. It’s a very different experience from reading the manga. Days repeat, scenarios are panned over, guitar riffs play in the background—it lingers, and lingers often. It gets to the point where it feels like its own, separate thing rather than an adaptation. It’s also closer—or rather, exactly aligned with my expectations of what Given would be like before I got into it. I wonder if it’s because most people got to know it from the anime? Which is to say: I feel like I finally know the “Given” I always saw people posting about.
Commenting on the music would require way more technical knowledge than what I have (which is zero), so I’ll just try to put down my general impressions. It sounds different from what I expected. The instruments feel like they’re demanding your attention, somehow? In the opening, the drums, the bass, the guitar all sound so cool (I’d even say refreshing). It is a story about music,after all. I was very curious about what “A Winter’s Song” sounded like (especially because when I was reading that part in the manga I put Asian Kung Fu Generation’s “Solanin” in the background and had the best experience of my life). The song isn’t bad, but I can’t say I like it. Despite that, the moment when Mafuyu just yells out took my breath away. There’s that intensity from the manga, achieved in a completely different way. It’s overwhelming. Only after that initial shock faded and I caught my breath was I able to cry. And that’s also how it was for Mafuyu, wasn’t it?




